“You should put your hands in the soil every day,” Anu said one of the evenings Shoaib had joined her and her family for dinner at their home in Himachal Pradesh, northern India. Anu relished her work with the soil, and she urged Shoaib to make a small garden while he was there on fieldwork. It was among the things in life she utterly held dear. After living through years of domestic violence, she felt that soil was the final substrate of belonging; when working the soils in the garden she described herself as being with the earth, even when her work in the garden exhausted her. She often complained of backache. Anu told Shoaib that working the soil was the way to stay grounded, the only relationship that mattered when everything else might fall apart. Soil care offered the possibility for renewal – for both the land and herself.
She found it virtuous and creative, even on occasions when her harvest was lost to sudden turns of weather or feral cattle. She found satisfaction in animating the soil, nurturing its qualities so a variety of her selections could eventually grow and prosper. Something more than use value or material prosperity was cultivated in Anu's garden. To Anu, there was something inexpressible and irreducible about soils, a sort of ontological attraction, for which she sometimes used the English word “energy”. Working the soil with her hands, she felt rewarded and recharged. On the other hand, working the familial bonds she had once held high hopes for now felt relatively unrewarding and disheartening. Working the soil had become important for her in unanticipated ways.
Born in the mid-80s, Anu grew up witnessing widespread social and ecological change. Across the Himalayan state, small apple orchards were emerging, girls began attending public schools and college, small-town markets expanded, newspapers and media proliferated – all accompanied by irreversible changes in food, vegetation, climate, social relations, and responsibilities. Not only were the relations to soil changing, but so were the relationalities of family, gender, caste, villages, and small towns. Agricultural intensification happened alongside diversification of non-farm livelihoods. Both the work of nature and the nature of work (Gidwani, 2000) experienced irreversible and uncertain change.
Analytically, “toil” pries open a tension between the virtues of hard work, weariness and hoped-for reward. Toil is a critical aspect of the nature of work acceptable to, or expected of, different social groups. Toil nests work in specific cultural, political and ecological contexts. Grounded in the soil relations of Western Himalaya, this article investigates the relation between human toil and the ability to care. What does it mean to care for others (including nonhuman others) in a world where sedimented habits and old ways of knowing and responding no longer offer a reliable means to renewal (Brown, 2024; Ghosh, 2018; Tsing, 2015)?
The toil for soil: Earthing agricultural care in the Western Himalaya
are integral to the cultivable soils of western Himalaya. Our aim is not to arbitrate
whether toil is bad or good, but to highlight three tensions. First, the tension between …
First published online April 1, 2026 The toil for soil: Earthing agricultural care in the Western Himalaya Syed Shoaib Ali https://orcid.org/0000-0002-1013-071X shoaib@theappletree.blog, Franklin Ginn, and Naomi Millner
The eThics of Yoga and The spiriT of godmen
even though he gestures toward catholic … The competitive structure of the free
market combined with the spirit of Hindutva turns the ultimate goal of yoga—the …
Can the Saree Speak? Exploring Tradition, Heritage and Beyond
UNESCO instruments, emphasizing its distinction from—yet partial convergence with—cultural
property. Tracing the saree’s historical trajectory—from ancient handloom traditions …
[PDF] Phantoms of the drains: imaginations of conflict in everyday infrastructures
that we are Hindus,’ a reflection on how Hindutva actors selectively fold Dalits into a
temporary alliance only when mobilizing them against Muslims. At other times, caste …
The Violence of Hindu Nationalist Statecraft
Violence: VD Savarkar and the Politics of History, Savarkar … As fact-finding reports
have subsequently demonstrated, the violence soon took a highly organized form …
[PDF] Anti-Muslim violence in India's religious ethnocracy
instrumental and/or epiphenomenal to Hindutva politics, but is also a part of the
processes and techniques involved in the social construction of security, institutional …
A man on a cellphone tower in Punjab is at centre of gathering protest for anti-sacrilege law
the rise of Hindutva in the rest of the country,” the observer said. Traders in and around
Samana alleged that pro-Khalistan slogans were frequently raised at the protest. …
[PDF] Anti-caste pedagogy as a personal and political statement
pedagogy in the context of international higher education, especially as the number
of Indian students overseas increases. Sircar explains how caste, a rigid social …
[HTML] Populism and the politics of constitutional (mis-) identity
nationalist vision centered on Hindu dominance and one that … This narrative firmly
anchors the identity of the nation in Hinduism—or, more precisely, in Hindutva …
[PDF] Colonial Legacies and Democratic Transformation: Institutional Continuity and Political Identity in Modi's India
decisions have shaped India’s contemporary political structure and national identity,
particularly under the leadership of Prime Minister Narendra Modi. A significant …
[PDF] RIGT WING POPULISM IN US AND INDIA: ANALYSIS OF NARENDRA MODI's AND DONALD TRUMP's FOREIGN POLICY
internal politics is following a “nationalism based on Hindutva” under the slogan of “Vishwaguru
(world leader)”. This slogan was declared openly in G20 summit which highlighted …
[PDF] DECOLONIZATION OF ISLAMIC FAMILY LAW IN INDONESIA: TRACING TRANSFORMATION AND CONTINUTIY
Indonesia by tracing its historical transformation, policy changes, and the continuity
of its legal practices from the colonial period to the post-reform era. Through a …
Collated by Tusar Nath Mohapatra
